We know that many Bar/Bat Mitzvah Celebrations have gotten way out of hand. Thousands have seen Rabbi Wolpe’s Washington Post article “Have we forgotten what Bar Mitzvahs are about?” although fewer may have read the Rabbi’s apology for what some have said was an angry tone.
Beyond the materialistic approach that some of these affairs take and the message it sends, there is another consequence of the Bar/Bat Mitzvah years, regardless of how ‘over the top’ and excessive the extravagance is.
That is the social rejection experienced by those that are left out, not invited—not considered ‘worthy’ of sharing the celebration.oii
The ones who aren’t ‘cool’ enough to be invited or who aren’t in the ‘in’ group.
The ones who get a sick, stinging feeling when finding out they’re one of the few kids who won’t be going to what should be a communal celebration of a life cycle event.
It is a Jewish experience within a Jewish context that leaves scars. This awful irony does not escape them.
During the Bar/Bat Mitzvah years, we would want them to feel wanted, accepted, and comfortable and instead they experience an extreme version of the already intense adolescent social pressures.
One parent told me that his son told him he was ‘never going back to that place’ referring to the synagogue that he felt failed him by allowing such obvious exclusionary behavior.
Here they are, ostensibly learning Jewish values, (B’tzelem Elokim, Kavod HaBriut, Tzniut, and many others) with a huge chasm between learning these values and what they’re actually experiencing in their lives…within the community of a synagogue no less.
How sad. We certainly make a lot of effort to make other environments fair (no scores in Little League?).
Can’t we figure this one out? Although the scenario above does not happen in every single synagogue, I know that you know it happens often enough for us not to ignore it.
Understandably, making rules and not allowing free choice in this area is extremely tough, but in not choosing to set policies, we are choosing and allowing our highly impressionable teens to be victims of this socially isolating experience.
And it’s just a shame that some teen’s experience of a Jewish religious rite becomes a place where popularity plays out.
With some effort, these issues might be solved in some creative ways. Our teens, at least in a Jewish environment, deserve a safe haven from some of the most painful social experiences of adolescence.
Quick, let’s think of some alternatives:
1. We go back to the ‘old-fashioned’ ways, and truly make this opportunity a communal experience.…held in the synagogue with the entire synagogue community plus friends and family included. Expensive? Not when done without the glitz and glamour.
2. Have all the families agree to invite everyone, no matter what type of celebration.
3. Discuss the social implications of this event with the teens, making it part of the supplementary school curriculum.
4. Families celebrating in that year agree to donate monies into a joint fund, and hold a celebration for everyone in the class at an agreed-upon time.
5. Raise awareness of this issue at parent education opportunities.
Do you have creative ways of dealing with this issue? I’d love to hear what some synagogues have worked out, I’m sure so many parents and Jewish educators would love to have some options. Please respond and share.
Photo credit: Wikipedia
- David Wolpe apologizes to showy bar mitzvah boy (jta.org)
- Motivators (cross-currents.com)
- How We Are Shortchanging Jewish Teens
- How to Make School Cool for Jewish Teens
December 31st, 2014 at 5:04 PM
[…] 3 “You’re Not Invited”: Teen Victims of the Bar/Bat Mitzvah Years and What To Do Abo… This post was written in 2013, but still made the list this […]